2-Get Estimates and Shop Around

Even if you've found a reputable garage or mechanic, that doesn't mean you can't shop around or get a second opinion if you think you're being fleeced, or if your BS sensor is going off. We've discussed the best way to do this before, but the big takeaways are simple: Get written estimates, and make sure they're valid for as long as you plan to do your shopping around. Then take your car to another mechanic—ideally another trustworthy one—for a second opinion. Make sure you don't share the first garage's diagnosis and estimate with the second one. See what the second garage says the problem is, and how much they're willing to charge you for it. If you like to play hardball, you can whip out the original estimate and see if the second mechanic is willing to undercut, has any ongoing specials, or willing to negotiate a lower labor rate or discount. You can even take the second opinion back to the original garage and see if they're willing to work with you. Be careful though, that kind of thing can easily backfire, and while you can save money on labor just by picking a shop with lower labor or parts costs, it shouldn't be your only consideration. If you want a semi-objective opinion on how much a repair should cost, head back to those car forums we just mentioned and ask the community there. You'll probably hear some stories from mechanics who have actually done that type of work, and are willing to tell you how much a good shop should charge. You can also check out previously mentioned AutoMD for average prices, especially compared to doing the repair yourself.